Monday, August 2, 2010

Semmanarai

Second Workshop with Kurumbas of Semmanarai

 Workshop exercises:

1.  Drawing their perspective of the forest




































2.   Self-portrait
 




3.   One word exercise- say whatever comes to your mind after I say the following words:
 Forest 
 Gooseberry, honey, medicinal herb, elephants, panther, bear
  
Honey 
God Rangaswami, masaniamma( first harvest is always offered to the god as a ritual), Biscoti climber, beeswax, Livelihood

History
 Changes or the lack of it in terms of worshipping, cash Crops not being sufficient anymore as means of livelihood, changing role of crops and cash,  no change in terms of marriage beliefs( no inter-cast marriages allowed still), the celebration of kumbhadeva on the peak of a hill

 Change
1.  Community cooking has grown over the years 
2.  Cross cultural participation has increased
3.  Kurumbas as a community are preferred to conduct the ceremonies amongst   other   communities, so they are really proud of being such an important part of other’s lives
4.  Land has changed as well as the land use pattern because of the extensive tea plantation 
5.  Before , they always used to have grains/millets at home for domestic use, now even though they sell crash crops to acquire provisions, its not sufficient because of the ever increasing rates of things in the regular economy
6.  Before, there wasn’t any fertilizer in the food, now even if they give money and buy food, it has chemicals
7.  Forest cover has changed due to rapid deforestation and tea plantation, it has caused migration of bees and other major changes in their lifestyle because they are basically forest people and their lives are intertwined with the forest and its produce.
-instant cash is not really that useful, since everything is so expensive
-Even though they are really attached to their old lifestyle, now wildlife conflict is really   difficult to deal with
-Movement/ travelling has increased outside the forest
- use of new technology like mobile phones and television which has made their lives convenient( they also realize the pros and cons of new age technology)

 Keystone
 -Their intervention has not only helped them with their livelihood by providing them regular wages, and new ways of sustaining themselves but also helped them revive their own history which they were slowly losing touch with
-They helped them see the use of beeswax and produce various by products with it which they used to go to waste before that
-revival of traditional culture is one of the biggest contributions ( *helped them regain their confidence in their culture and construct their own identities out of the traditional values)

Money
-Only enough to sustain their basic needs( which is not sufficient like any of us
-If they had more than that , they would invest in their fields
-Send kids to better schools, than the govt. Provided (realize the importance of good education)
-Invest in personal/household objects
It has brought about a change which they like



There is a contradiction here, some of them feel like they were happier earlier, when they were just living off the forest, with introduction of money in their lives , it has made their life more difficult, while some of them feel that it has brought about changes which were needed and those changes make them happy and their lives more convenient. A shift in mindset can be seen.



Insights
They go through major risks to just obtain the honey, depending on their beliefs and traditions.
The process is really systematic and each person has a role to play.
Their lives revolve around the forest, and their beliefs, honey is everything to them.
They are seemingly comfortable with the transition in their lifestyle.
The resources are not enough.
In the effort to provide them with resources and employment, the government has changed the entire land use pattern, and the forest cover which is having major implications on their lifestyle and the forest which is intertwined.
Because the government provides them with a daily wage to work in the tea plantations, they prefer doing that than actually carrying out their traditional practice of honey hunting, because the government job gives them more security. As a result, slowly their traditional practices are being
forgotten. Keystone is trying its best to help them retain their identity which is attached to those forests and its produce and their traditional practices using different methods.
Marketing their forest produce which is locally processed as well is just one step towards providing them with a means to sustain their cultural identity as well as their livelihood.
How much change is good? If they want to let go of their cultural identity and merge with the rest of us, is that okay? Is convenience the only reason or lack of resources the major reason for their need to change? Is it fair to provide them with a means of livelihood which makes them forget their culture in place of nothing?
 





 

Nilgiri Documentation Centre


The visit to the Documentation Centre was also quite useful. I went there in order to find out about work done by other artists in that area, to get a different perspective than mine. It is a place of historical significance set up in 1819 by John Sullivan, collector of then Coimbatore, an English civil servant whose name is intimately associated with the early growth of the Nilgiris.

 











 











I went through some useful books, and also saw really old pictures of all the tribal groups in the Nilgiris which gave me an idea of the changes that have come about in their lifestyle. I also came across some paintings of the Nilgiris and the indigenous people.



Keystone’s inputs/essentials for brand building


Meeting with the organization representatives- Mr Mathew John and Sneh

The Keystone office

 Points covered
-The value and importance of last forest as a brand should be reflected through the branding, should be a priority
-their cultural/traditional values should be reflected( bee songs,  sacred groves)
-them being indigenous people always takes a backseat, which shouldn’t happen this time
-biodiversity, organic
-material used for the packaging should also reflect the same values
-recycling
-Main attention: biodiversity and forest people
-Socially relevant cause, the organization’s support to them for a sustainable economy should also be paid attention to
-Local Processing and value addition
-the need to build the local market (apart from the indigenous crowd)
-suggestion made to include applications and effects of the product in the packaging

Hasanur


Hasanur Production Centre
It is located in a village called Hasanur which is close to Coimbatore. It is mainy inhabited by the Irulas. The Centre itslef is run by 7-12 locals. They have a shop also which caters to locals. They produce different kinds of honey, spices, beeswax balm, candy and pickles.


 












 
 











First part of the workshop
Number of people who participated- 7
I gave them all A4 sheets and pencils/pens and asked them to draw their perspective of the forest. I don’t know how successful I was in getting my point across to the person translating for me, and then how much of that, they understood. I told them it should be as personal as possible. The point of this exercise was, firstly to get them a little comfortable around me and vice-versa, and most importantly, to understand their perspective of “identity”. The closest association I could think of, was the forest because their lives are so intertwined with it. I wanted to see how they associate with it and in what ways the drastic change in their lifestyles have affected their thinking.
Initially , they seemed very hesitant about drawing, but I tried telling them that it doesn’t necessarily have to be pretty, but more personal. Again, I am not sure if they got that point.


 

 








































 




















 

















 

















Second part of the workshop

Number of people who participated- 6
The next exercise was story-telling, I asked them to relate any mythical/historical/personal tales which they remember. Not all of them spoke, and also, since it was evening they had started to get restless to go home. Whatever I understood from those broken stories was that all their stories mostly revolve around the forest and honey, that is what they think of as their life. I am not sure if that can be termed as an identity. But their lives have been interwoven with nature for so long, that it is difficult to see through the change in their mindset





 
















 -Most of the women working there travel 22kms back and forth everyday. But they seemed very innovative and efficient in terms of optimum utilization of the available resource
-They keep trying to come up with new products using forest produce.
-They have a local market as well, and a local organizing head for their village.
-All the people working there(Irula community) seem to be well aware.
-Most of their life and culture revolves around honey hunting, that being there major source of livelihood also.

Second Visit


In my second visit to the Nilgiris for research, I visited
-the Hasanur Production Centre Situated in a village called Hasanur near Coimbatore
-the Keystone office in Kotagiri
 -the Documentation Centre in Kotagiri
-the Semmanarai Production Centre run by a Kurumba settlement in Semmanarai
-the Nilgiri library in Ooty
-the local market in Ooty.

The main purpose of this visit was to interact with tribals behind the production of the Last Forest Honey, get to know their perspective on their fast changing identity. Also, to assess the local market and competing brands for a better understanding of the brand’s positioning in the market.



I started with the Production Centre in Hasanur, I met the people who run that centre. All of them belonged to the Irula community. I conducted a short workshop with them to get their side of the story. Language was a major barrier, but I managed with the head of the centre translating for me. It was a very nice experience, with all of them eagerly responding to my questions. Most of the women working there, travel some 22kms back and forth to this centre. But they seemed very happy about being a part of the whole process.

At the Keystone office, I met some new people who I hadn’t met the last time I visited. They gave me a clearer picture of their requirements for the brand and packaging. They were really helpful with organizing my visit to the Documentation Centre and the Semmanarai production Centre and information about the local market in Ooty.



My second part of the workshop was at the Semmanarai Production Centre which was located in the middle of the forest. The people here belonged to the Kurumba community. They were also very generous with their time and patience. But, this time I was more confident about the questions since the person translating for me seemed to have a better understanding of what I was trying to do.

 
In Ooty, I visited shops which sell mostly local produce and also bigger brands. I covered as many shops as I could, since it was raining heavily throughout. But, I got an overall idea of the kind of packaging the local brands use, and also about the competing bigger brands, the target audience. This research also gave me an idea of the position of Last Forest Honey in the local market.
Overall, it was a very productive trip. The details will be discussed in my later posts.

Keystone

 
What they do and why, their role in the lives of the communities

The lower reaches of the Nilgiris, a part of the Western Ghats are still home to a number of tribal settlements and retain relatively good forest cover. This region is also important because it is a critical watershed and part of the Nilgiri Biosphere Reserve. Even though it is rich in flora and fauna, this area is under threat. Some of the factors responsible for its degradation are:

-Unsuitable land use (tea plantations)
-Extensive use of pesticides- killing insect life
-Clear felling of large forest tracts
-Teak monoculture- reducing diversity
-Forest fires- destroying habitat
-Drastic shift from land-based economy to wage-based economy
       Today honey hunters are faced with a changed way of life through a new set of circumstances. Government development programmes, growing economic opportunity and restrictions on the use of forest produce are causing a shift in the cultural and natural ethos of the hill people, making honey hunting a rare and endangered activity.

Colonising the hive with bees















The Apiary at Semmanarai























A survey on honeyhunters and beekeepers in Tamil Nadu during 1994 helped Keystone to choose a base in the Nilgiris. The main reasons for selecting this area were the existing hunter-gatherer communities, their highly skilled honey-hunting practices, and the need for action, documentation and support for their traditional activities and lifestyle. Besides, the good vegetation in some areas would support their initial activity of beekeeping and experiments in Appropriate technology.

Keystone’s intervention has been mainly in the field of Beekeeping. This covers comprehensively all important aspects related to training and maintenance, technology application, hygienic extraction of honey, processing of beeswax, etc. Keeping bees in hives not only adds income to the family, but also aids pollination to the crops and the nearby forest species.



Appropriate technology in Beekeeping

Finding the conventional way of beekeeping difficult for tribals to grasp, and also being expensive, a new technology has been developed. This is the Mountain Hive made out of bamboo and forest vines and packed with local binding materials. This hive is woven by local artisans, and is affordable, also has easy handling and maintenance techniques.



Making the Mountain Hive

Monitoring disease in the colonies
Hands on training on bees and beekeeping


Honey extraction
 
Honey Extraction by an Irula tribal


Last Forest Honey in the market


Products made with Beeswax  
Slabs of beeswax








Beeswax Balm
Beeswax Candles











 Once the combs were collected, they were squeezed to get honey and the waste(beeswax) was usually thrown. Keystone provides marketing support to these tribals and has a processing centre to bottle and sell it under the brand name of Last Forest Honey. They are also trained to hygienically drain out the honey instead of squeezing it and processing the combs to get beeswax which has a high market value.










Beeswax lamps